Toronto Baseball Insider has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Blue Jays or MLB

Eric Lauer reveals Blue Jays were unaware of injury during loss to Angels


Victor William
Apr 23, 2026  (11:07)
Toronto Blue Jays pitcher Eric Lauer (56) reacts after giving up a solo home run to Arizona Diamondbacks third baseman Nolan Arenado (28) during the fourth inning at Chase Field.
Photo credit: Joe Camporeale-Imagn Images

Eric Lauer put John Schneider in a tough spot by admitting the Blue Jays did not really know about the neck issue he had been managing.

That changed the story around Lauer's exit right away. This was no longer just a pitcher leaving a game with tape behind his neck. It became a communication problem.
Lauer said he had been dealing with it for a couple of days. He also made clear that Schneider and the coaching staff may not have noticed it before seeing the tape during the game.
That matters because Schneider had already said he only became aware of it after spotting the tape himself. He checked with Lauer in the moment and was told the left-hander felt fine.
Now Lauer's own words add a sharper layer. He said it was not an injury risk, but more of a reminder to make sure he was feeling a couple of things that were a little tight.
That explanation may calm some fear about a serious absence. But it also opens another question for Toronto: why was a pitcher managing visible tightness without making sure the staff fully knew?
For a club already juggling innings, that is not a small detail. Schneider can work around performance dips. Hidden physical issues are harder to manage.

Lauer's explanation creates as many questions as answers

The Blue Jays have leaned on Lauer in more ways than one this season. He has moved between roles, covered bulk innings, and helped stabilize a pitching staff that has not had much room for surprises.
That is why the timing lands the way it does. When a pitcher says he has been feeling something for a few days, even if he insists it is minor, the dugout is going to hear it differently.
Lauer was also careful with his wording. He did not describe it as an injury, and that distinction matters. Players pitch through tightness all the time, especially in April when routines are still settling.
But the tape made it public, and the manager's reaction made it bigger. Schneider clearly was not expecting to learn about a possible issue by seeing it on the field.
That is where the awkward part comes in for Toronto. If Lauer truly believed it was only a physical cue and nothing more, he probably saw no reason to make it a bigger conversation. The Blue Jays may not see it that way.
Managers and pitching coaches need the full picture, especially with a staff already piecing together starts and bullpen coverage. Even minor tightness can change workload, pitch usage, or recovery plans.
So Lauer may be right that this is not a real injury story. But once he admitted the staff did not really know, it became a trust and communication story too.
And for the Blue Jays, that can matter almost as much as the tape itself.
POLL
1 HOUR AGO|26 ANSWERS
Eric Lauer reveals Blue Jays were unaware of injury during loss to Angels

Should Eric Lauer have told Blue Jays management sooner about the neck tightness ?


BLUE JAYS INSIDER
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT