Blue Jays Insider has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Blue Jays or MLB

Blue Jays Insider Polls

Vote and see what other Blue Jays fans are saying.

POLL
12 hours ago · 45 responses
Blue Jays add 3 players to their 40-man roster to protect from Rule-5 Draft

Did the Blue Jays make a mistake leaving Jay Harry unprotected?

Yes51.1%(23 votes)
No48.9%(22 votes)
POLL
13 hours ago · 14 responses
Blue Jays face Rule 5 protection deadline tonight at 6 p.m. with some big decisions to make

Should the Blue Jays protect Jay Harry from the Rule 5 Draft?

Yes42.9%(6 votes)
No57.1%(8 votes)
POLL
14 hours ago · 47 responses
Former Blue Jay Joey Loperfido harshly let go by the Astros

Did the Blue Jays lose the Joey Loperfido for Jesús Sánchez trade?

Yes68.1%(32 votes)
No31.9%(15 votes)
POLL
16 hours ago · 45 responses
Blue Jays release four pitchers ahead of Rule 5 protection deadline

Are the Blue Jays right to overhaul their minor league pitching depth?

Yes91.1%(41 votes)
No8.9%(4 votes)
POLL
18 hours ago · 39 responses
Blue Jays miss on Dustin May as signs major 3-year deal

Are the Blue Jays better off missing out on Dustin May at $52.5 million?

Yes97.4%(38 votes)
No2.6%(1 vote)
POLL
19 hours ago · 30 responses
Reasoning behind why the Blue Jays released Peyton Williams revealed

Should the Blue Jays have kept the Iowa Meat Truck on the 40-man roster?

Yes33.3%(10 votes)
No66.7%(20 votes)
POLL
20 hours ago · 74 responses
Blue Jays linked to massive $125 million deal

Should the Blue Jays give Trevor Rogers five years and $125 million?

Yes45.9%(34 votes)
No54.1%(40 votes)
POLL
21 hours ago · 94 responses
4 teams pushing to trade for Blue Jays second baseman Ernie Clement

Should the Blue Jays trade Ernie Clement once they add a new infielder?

Yes31.9%(30 votes)
No68.1%(64 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 105 responses
Blue Jays 3 non-tender candidates revealed

Should the Blue Jays non-tender Davis Schneider before Friday's deadline?

Yes69.5%(73 votes)
No30.5%(32 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 131 responses
Charlee McAdoo's time in Toronto could be ending after latest update

Should the Blue Jays trade Charles McAdoo this offseason?

Yes29%(38 votes)
No71%(93 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 41 responses
Lockout would lock injured Blue Jays out of team doctors

Will a lockout set back the Blue Jays' injured players for 2027?

Yes56.1%(23 votes)
No43.9%(18 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 43 responses
Former Blue Jays star pitcher back on the free agent market

Should the Blue Jays bring back Matt Gage on a minor league deal?

Yes32.6%(14 votes)
No67.4%(29 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 115 responses
Trey Yesavage named in a trade the Blue Jays foolish to make

Would you trade Trey Yesavage, Addison Barger and Johnny King for James Wood?

Yes0.9%(1 vote)
No99.1%(114 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 64 responses
José Berríos' might not be ready for this upcoming season after all

Will José Berríos pitch for the Blue Jays before the end of 2027?

Yes62.5%(40 votes)
No37.5%(24 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 168 responses
Addison Barger linked to massive 3-for-1 blockbuster trade

Should the Blue Jays trade Addison Barger, Nolan Perry and Braydon Fisher for Ketel Marte?

Yes30.4%(51 votes)
No69.6%(117 votes)
POLL
NOV 16 · 322 responses
Tarik Skubal asking price for the Blue Jays finally revealed

Should the Blue Jays walk away from Tarik Skubal at more than $325 million?

Yes72.4%(233 votes)
No27.6%(89 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 64 responses
Blue Jays join in on multiple teams going after former Brewers pitcher

Should the Blue Jays sign Dustin May as a high-upside rotation gamble?

Yes34.4%(22 votes)
No65.6%(42 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 174 responses
Blue Jays linked to blockbuster 1-for-1 trade with the Nationals involving Brandon Valenzuela

Should the Blue Jays trade Brandon Valenzuela for Zach Neto?

Yes36.8%(64 votes)
No63.2%(110 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 72 responses
Blue Jays pitcher Jameson Taillon calls MLB's for CBA post

Is Jameson Taillon right about MLB's motives in the CBA fight?

Yes63.9%(46 votes)
No36.1%(26 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 163 responses
Max Scherzer makes big decision regarding his future in the MLB

Should the Blue Jays bring back Max Scherzer for a 20th season?

Yes72.4%(118 votes)
No27.6%(45 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 81 responses
Blue Jays looking at multiple options to improve their starting rotation

Should the Blue Jays trade Ernie Clement if they land a new second baseman?

Yes32.1%(26 votes)
No67.9%(55 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 74 responses
Blue Jays release another outfielder in latest roster shuffle

Are the Blue Jays right to prioritize specific tools over outfield depth?

Yes77%(57 votes)
No23%(17 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 108 responses
Blue Jays enter bidding war with the Mets, Phillies and Dodgers for star pitcher

Should the Blue Jays outbid the Dodgers and Phillies for Jonathan Loaisiga?

Yes35.2%(38 votes)
No64.8%(70 votes)
POLL
NOV 15 · 211 responses
Explanation behind reports of Blue Jays completing trade for Ketel Marte

Should the Blue Jays give Ketel Marte a $135 million extension in a trade?

Yes22.7%(48 votes)
No77.3%(163 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 87 responses
Blue Jays linked to $45 million deal involving Nick Pivetta

Is three years and $45 million a fair price for Nick Pivetta?

Yes64.4%(56 votes)
No35.6%(31 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 264 responses
3-Player potential trade package announced involving Sean Keys

Should the Blue Jays trade Sean Keys, Johnny King and Ricky Tiedemann for Willy Adames?

Yes37.1%(98 votes)
No62.9%(166 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 96 responses
Blue Jays linked to Triple-Crown winner Teruaki Sato

Should the Blue Jays sign Teruaki Sato to play left field?

Yes84.4%(81 votes)
No15.6%(15 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 197 responses
Blue Jays have officially checked in on blockbuster trade to replace Ernie Clement

Should the Blue Jays trade for Ketel Marte if Arizona lowers its asking price?

Yes47.2%(93 votes)
No52.8%(104 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 92 responses
Blue Jays decide to release infielder Peyton Williams despite incredible season

Did the Blue Jays make a mistake releasing Peyton Williams?

Yes33.7%(31 votes)
No66.3%(61 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 225 responses
Alejandro Kirk and his wife make special off-the-field announcement

Is Alejandro Kirk the most important player to keep on the Blue Jays roster?

Yes71.1%(160 votes)
No28.9%(65 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 97 responses
Blue Jays unexpectedly release shortstop

Are the Blue Jays right to clear out minor league shortstops for younger signings?

Yes77.3%(75 votes)
No22.7%(22 votes)
POLL
NOV 14 · 130 responses
Former Blue Jays catcher Tyler Heineman signs with Angels

Do the Blue Jays need to add a veteran catcher after Tyler Heineman's exit?

Yes48.5%(63 votes)
No51.5%(67 votes)
POLL
NOV 13 · 166 responses
Blue Jays and Dodgers reliever Alex Vesia in discussion

Should the Blue Jays sign Alex Vesia to pair with Mason Fluharty?

Yes89.8%(149 votes)
No10.2%(17 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 13 · 222 responses
Blue Jays contract offer update on Shane Bieber, Kevin Gausman and Max Scherzer

Which reunion makes the most sense: should the Blue Jays bring back Kevin Gausman?

Yes77.5%(172 votes)
No22.5%(50 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 13 · 210 responses
Blue Jays expected to trade Davis Schneider after latest update

Should the Blue Jays trade Davis Schneider this offseason?

Yes61.9%(130 votes)
No38.1%(80 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 13 · 274 responses
George Springer predicted to sign with Blue Jays divisional rivals

Would it bother you to see George Springer sign with the Red Sox?

Yes66.8%(183 votes)
No33.2%(91 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 13 · 160 responses
Blue Jays surprisingly release 4 players following GM Meetings

Are the Blue Jays releasing too many minor leaguers this offseason?

Yes34.4%(55 votes)
No65.6%(105 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 13 · 125 responses
Full update on Ross Atkins' plans following GM meeetings

Should the Blue Jays move Spencer Miles into the rotation full-time in 2027?

Yes62.4%(78 votes)
No37.6%(47 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 13 · 99 responses
Blue Jays, Yankees and Mets chasing Jonathan Loaisiga in latest update

Should the Blue Jays outbid the Yankees and Mets for Jonathan Loaisiga?

Yes40.4%(40 votes)
No59.6%(59 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 13 · 105 responses
Ross Atkins speaks on Louis Varland's award winning season

Should the Blue Jays sign Louis Varland to a contract extension this winter?

Yes94.3%(99 votes)
No5.7%(6 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 102 responses
Blue Jays check in on big time relievers to add to their bullpen

Should the Blue Jays sign A.J. Minter to strengthen their left-handed relief?

Yes79.4%(81 votes)
No20.6%(21 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 152 responses
Blue Jays linked to $105 million trade

Should the Blue Jays trade for Ketel Marte despite his issues in Arizona?

Yes27.6%(42 votes)
No72.4%(110 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 227 responses
Blue Jays issue official statement regarding Anthony Santander's controversial comments

Is the Blue Jays' apology enough without releasing Anthony Santander?

Yes28.6%(65 votes)
No71.4%(162 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 131 responses
The exact size of contract Blue Jays offered to Kyle Tucker last season revealed

Will the Blue Jays finally land a top free-agent bat this winter?

Yes78.6%(103 votes)
No21.4%(28 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 109 responses
Blue Jays urged to avoid signing Luis Arraez this winter due to growing concerns

Should the Blue Jays pass on Luis Arraez despite his .310 average?

Yes61.5%(67 votes)
No38.5%(42 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 130 responses
1-for-1 trade pitcher in which Toronto would land 2023 2nd overall pick

Should the Blue Jays trade Sean Keys and Ricky Tiedemann for Dylan Crews?

Yes35.4%(46 votes)
No64.6%(84 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 99 responses
Blue Jays show interest in Brandon Lowe at GM meetings

Should the Blue Jays outbid the Yankees for Brandon Lowe?

Yes63.6%(63 votes)
No36.4%(36 votes)

Voting closed

POLL
NOV 12 · 92 responses
Former Blue Jays pitcher Julian Merryweather back on the market after being released

Should the Blue Jays give Julian Merryweather another chance on a minor league deal?

Yes50%(46 votes)
No50%(46 votes)

Voting closed