Kevin Pillar has pitched a Brandon Valenzuela for Zach Neto swap between the Blue Jays and Angels. The former Toronto outfielder admits it's “wishful thinking.”
He floated the idea on the Nov. 13 edition of Blue Bird Territory. “This is in no way saying I don't like the guy or value the guy, but his name came up,” he said of Valenzuela.
His logic starts with Anaheim's catching situation. “Obviously, they went through Logan O'Hoppe. That didn't work. They traded him,” Pillar said.
He added that Valenzuela “did enough this year to show a lot of teams he could probably handle a full-time job.”
Neto produced a big season. He hit 27 homers and scored 102 runs over 157 games.
Why would the Angels listen? Money and timing.
Zach Neto's first arbitration year could open a Blue Jays door
Neto, who turns 26 in January, is heading into his first year of arbitration. “He's getting a little bit more expensive,” Pillar noted.
The Angels also aren't close to contending, Pillar said, with new ownership not yet fully in place.
The clubs have a working relationship, too. They connected on the José Soriano trade last summer.
Valenzuela was a Gold Glove finalist in 2026, though he hit just .222 at the plate.
This is the kind of return that justifies moving Valenzuela. The Jays shouldn't trade him for a utility bat, but a 27-homer middle infielder entering his prime is a different conversation.
Trading the catcher for Neto is like swapping a great spare tire for a new engine. You lose some safety, but the car goes a lot faster.
Realistically, Kurt Suzuki's club would likely want more than one player. And Alejandro Kirk, who played just 79 games in 2026, would need a reliable backup.
Ricky Romero also weighed in on Jazz Chisholm Jr. this week, calling him “a quality bat.” But if Neto is truly available, Ross Atkins should pick up the phone first.


















