The Blue Jays won't be able to scout Max Scherzer's comeback bid once the lockout starts. The veteran plans to test his arm in informal “lockout games” this winter.
Scherzer told the New York Post's Jon Heyman he'll gauge his desire to keep pitching during the offseason downtime. A 20th big-league season is on the table.
Those lockout games are informal scrimmages with pro or pro-adjacent players. Because he's an MLBPA member, clubs won't be allowed to watch.
That makes any decision a leap of faith. Toronto would have to rely on what it already knows.
His final 2026 start was classic Mad Max. He initially refused to leave the game, barking at John Schneider to get back to the dugout.
But is that fire enough? Not on its own.
Max Scherzer's injury history clouds a possible 20th season
He hasn't thrown more than 85 innings in a season since 2023. Back, forearm, shoulder and hamstring issues have all played a role.
Over two seasons in Toronto, he posted a 5.46 ERA with a 5.05 FIP. The numbers confirm a pitcher slowing down.
His former teammate Justin Verlander made it clear 2026 was his final season. Scherzer never did.
After the 2025 World Series, he made it clear he wanted one more shot at a third title. He started Game 7 that year, coming within reach of it.
Toronto should only revisit Scherzer if he's willing to sign cheap after the lockout. Committing to a pitcher nobody's allowed to watch would be a gamble even by Ross Atkins' standards.
Signing Scherzer blind is like buying a house without an inspection. The history is famous, but you have no idea what's behind the walls.
Agent Scott Boras has insisted he's “far from Max'd out.” That's a sales pitch, not a scouting report.
His competitive drive has never been in doubt. Whether his body agrees will be decided far from any scout's radar gun.


















