The Blue Jays have missed out on Dustin May, who agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million deal with the White Sox. His agent, Craig Rose of Paragon, confirmed the agreement.
Toronto was one of nine teams in the mix, according to The Athletic's Jim Bowden. The Cubs, Nationals, Orioles, Giants, Reds, Guardians and Marlins were also involved.
In the end, Will Venable's White Sox won the bidding. The deal averages $17.5 million per season.
That's a lot for a pitcher coming off a rough finish. May posted a 5.65 ERA over 10 starts with the Brewers after a deadline trade.
Teams bet on his youth and stuff instead. At 29, he was one of the youngest starters available, with a fastball that still grades as a weapon.
Should Toronto be disappointed? Not really.
Losing Dustin May keeps Toronto focused on bigger rotation targets
Ross Atkins wants a starter “who could start a playoff game.” May has the talent, but not the track record that description demands.
The Jays still have plenty of options. They're set to meet with Tarik Skubal, and Michael King, Nick Pivetta and Trevor Rogers remain available.
Lower-cost upside arms are out there, too. Clay Holmes, Foster Griffin and Mike Soroka all fit the profile Toronto was chasing with May.
Missing on May is no loss at that price. Paying that kind of money for upside alone would have been a gamble Toronto doesn't need to take.
It's like getting outbid on a car with a great engine and a shaky history. A little disappointing, but you'll probably thank yourself later.
The market is clearly moving fast. With the lockout looming Dec. 1, more starters could come off the board quickly.
That puts pressure on the front office. Toronto hasn't made a major signing yet.
May is gone, and the clock is ticking. Atkins needs his rotation answer soon, before the rest of the market follows May's lead.


















