Bleacher Report predicts the Blue Jays will give Trevor Rogers a five-year, $125 million deal. The former Orioles lefty would fill Toronto's biggest rotation gap.

Zachary D. Rymer admitted it's “going out on a bit of a limb,” since the Jays haven't been firmly connected to Rogers yet.

His reasoning is simple. Toronto needs starting pitching and has been “poking around the top pitchers on the market,” including Michael King and Tarik Skubal.

Rymer called Rogers “an obvious pivot” if those two fall through. He also has plenty of experience against AL East opponents.

His 2026 in Baltimore was solid, not spectacular. He went 10-11 with a 4.03 ERA and 157 strikeouts over 30 games.

So why the big price? Because of what he did the year before.

Trevor Rogers' 1.81 ERA in 2025 drives his market

Rogers was dominant in 2025, going 9-3 over 18 starts. He also finished 2026 strong with a 2.53 ERA in five September starts.

He'd fill a specific need, too. Toronto's projected rotation of Dylan Cease, Trey Yesavage, José Soriano and Cody Ponce is entirely right-handed.

Ross Atkins wants a starter “who could start a playoff game.” Rogers' best version fits that bill.

The question is which version shows up. His 2025 dominance came in a limited sample, and 2026 was far more ordinary.

Rogers is the right lefty target, but five years is too long. A four-year deal would protect Toronto if his 2025 turns out to be the outlier rather than the norm.

Paying for his 2025 is like buying a house based on its best photo. You need to see the whole place before signing for five years.

Other lefties are on the market, too. Foster Griffin and David Peterson offer cheaper paths if the price climbs.

The prediction is bold, and the fit makes sense. If Atkins strikes out on Skubal and King, Rogers could quickly become Toronto's top target.