Matt Gage has elected free agency after a season with the Giants. The former Blue Jays lefty is back on the market at 33.

His 2026 in San Francisco was uneven. He made 34 appearances with a 5.60 ERA.

He also struggled in a brief minor league stint, allowing a 10.38 ERA over four games between Single-A San Jose and Triple-A Sacramento.

Toronto fans remember a much better version. The Jays signed him to a minor league deal in November 2021.

He made his MLB debut with Toronto on June 6, 2022, in a win at Kansas City. He went on to post a 1.38 ERA over 11 games that season.

So why didn't he stick? Roster math.

Matt Gage's Blue Jays stint ended on the waiver wire

The Astros claimed him off waivers in February 2023. He's since pitched for Houston, Detroit and San Francisco.

His short run in Toronto was a reminder of how quickly lefty depth can disappear.

That issue remains today. The Jays are searching for another reliable left-hander to pair with Mason Fluharty, who led the majors in appearances.

They've shown interest in Alex Vesia and checked on A.J. Minter. Those are the kind of high-leverage arms Toronto needs.

A reunion with Gage only makes sense as a no-risk minor league deal. His 2026 numbers don't justify a 40-man spot when the Jays are chasing much better lefties.

Gage is like a spare charger buried in a drawer. It might work in a pinch, but you wouldn't rely on it every day.

He'll likely land somewhere on a minor league contract. Lefties with big-league experience tend not to stay unsigned for long.

For Toronto, the priority is clear. Ross Atkins needs a proven lefty first, and depth arms like Gage can wait until the bigger moves are done.