Toronto Baseball Insider has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Blue Jays or MLB

Jeff Hoffman responds to being removed as closer


Victor William
Apr 24, 2026  (4:45 PM)
Toronto Blue Jays pitcher Jeff Hoffman (23) throws against the Los Angeles Angels during the ninth inning at Angel Stadium.
Photo credit: Gary A. Vasquez-Imagn Images

Jeff Hoffman gave John Schneider the answer the Blue Jays needed after losing the closer job, even if the situation still stings.

Hoffman said he wants Toronto in the best position to win, and if that means he is not the sole closer right now, then that is what it is. He also admitted the Blue Jays have other relievers doing the job better than he is at the moment.
That matters because it strips away any idea of a public fight. Hoffman did not push back. He did not duck the truth. He met it head-on.
And for this bullpen, that response carries weight. Toronto has already moved to a shared ninth-inning setup in the short term while Hoffman shifts into lower-leverage spots. Ross Atkins said Friday the club still believes Hoffman will get very important outs.
So this is not a burial. It is a reset. The Blue Jays are trying to get a talented arm back on track without asking him to carry every save chance while the inning keeps getting louder.
Hoffman's honesty also fits the way Schneider has spoken about him this week. The manager said the club wanted to support him, talk through what was going on, and put him in spots to have success.

Toronto needs Hoffman useful, not proud

That is why his quote lands so well inside a clubhouse. Closers are wired to want the ninth. But relievers who help teams win usually understand when the role has to shift for a while.
Hoffman sounds like he gets that. By admitting other Blue Jays relievers are doing it better right now, he took some pressure off the staff and some noise out of the room.
That does not erase the problem. The Blue Jays signed Hoffman to be a late-game weapon, not a project. The first month has forced them to rethink that plan faster than anyone wanted.
But the response still matters. A reliever can lose the closer role and make it messy, or he can lose it and give his team room to fix things. Hoffman chose the second path.
That gives Schneider a better chance to use him in meaningful middle spots, build his rhythm back, and maybe let the ninth find him again later instead of forcing it now.
For the Blue Jays, that may be the best outcome available. Jeff Hoffman is no longer the lone closer, but his own words showed he understands the bigger point. Right now, the team needs outs more than titles.
POLL
1 HOUR AGO|41 ANSWERS
Jeff Hoffman responds to being removed as closer

Did Jeff Hoffman handle losing the Blue Jays closer role the right way ?


BLUE JAYS INSIDER
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT