Photo credit: John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images
Joe Siddall is officially the frontrunner to replace the legendary Buck Martinez, and this succession plan feels like it was written in the stars.
Following Buck's emotional retirement announcement, the immediate question on everyone's mind was: "Who could possibly fill those shoes?"
The answer has been sitting right there in the studio all along.
Siddall (Undrafted Free Agent, signed 1987 by Montreal) isn't just a "fill-in"; he is a former big-league catcher with a tactical brain that rivals Buck’s.
Having worked alongside Jerry Howarth on radio and Jamie Campbell on Blue Jays Central, Siddall has earned his stripes the hard way.
His journey from a defensive catcher in the 90s (playing for Montreal, Florida, and Detroit) to a top-tier analyst mirrors Buck's own path perfectly.
He sees the game through the same mask, dissecting pitch sequencing and defensive positioning with a clarity that fans appreciate.
The catcher fraternity continues
There is a poetic justice in replacing one catcher with another, ensuring the "voice" of the broadcast remains analytical and player-focused.
Siddall has already proven he can handle the booth, stepping in admirably when Buck battled health issues in recent seasons.
He doesn't try to be Buck—he brings his own calm, modern perspective, often leaning into data without losing the human element.
Partnering him with Dan Shulman would create arguably the most intelligent broadcast duo in the entire league.
Fans have already embraced him because he respects the history of the team while understanding the modern metrics that drive today's game.
He isn't an outsider coming in to "fix" the broadcast; he is a family member stepping up to the head of the table.
This is the safe, smart, and sentimental choice that respects Buck's legacy while turning the page to a new chapter.
Joe Siddall is ready for the first pitch, and Toronto is ready to listen.
Also read on Toronto Baseball Insider :
Reasoning behind Buck Martinez' sudden retirement revealed
Reasoning behind Buck Martinez' sudden retirement revealed
| POLL | ||
FEVRIER 6|509 ANSWERS New details regarding Buck Martinez' replacement announced Is Joe Siddall the best candidate to replace Buck Martinez permanently? | ||
| Yes | 397 | 78 % |
| No | 112 | 22 % |
| List of polls | ||