New development between the Toronto Blue Jays and Eugenio Suarez

On Monday a signing proposal floated a Toronto pivot, sign Suárez for thump, then trade an outfielder to unclog the roster. It is roster Tetris, not fantasy baseball.

The appeal is obvious, Suarez just hit 49 homers with a .526 slug and an .824 OPS in 2025. That is a middle-order hammer, even if the batting average sat at .228.

From my couch, this feels like the kind of move that either wins October or makes April weird.

Here's why it gets messy fast. The Blue Jays already signed Kazuma Okamoto to play third, and the whole point of that deal was adding impact without scrambling the defense nightly.

If Suárez arrives anyway, he probably plays third most days, and Addison Barger becomes a full-time outfield solution again. Barger's 2025, 21 homers with a .755 OPS, screams «keep him in the lineup.»

So who moves? The quieter rumor lane has pointed at the lesser outfielders, with Ken Rosenthal's reporting mentioning names like Nathan Lukes, Myles Straw, and Joey Loperfido as possible trade chips.

That's where it gets emotional, because Lukes was legitimately useful.

He hit .255/.323/.407 with 12 homers and 65 RBIs in 2025, and that's not nothing from a depth guy.

The other wrinkle is the DH and corner-outfield traffic.

George Springer just posted a monster .309 season with 32 homers, and Anthony Santander is already under a big-ticket deal, so Toronto can't pretend those spots are empty.

My take, Suárez is a fun idea, but it only works if the trade return upgrades a clear weakness instead of just shuffling bodies.

This could be a very interesting move since not only could the Blue Jays bring in a solid bat but it would force them to make a trade which could further improve their lineup.

Also read on Toronto Baseball Insider :
MLB makes announcement regarding Toronto Blue Jays veteran George Springer