Toronto Blue Jays announce unforeseen update in Eric Lauer arbitration hearing
|
Victor William
Feb 5, 2026 (5:14 PM)
|
|
Photo credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images
Eric Lauer and the Blue Jays have wrapped up their arbitration hearing, and the outcome next week could be far more significant than just a salary figure.
The lefty reliever, who became an unexpected hero for Toronto’s bullpen last season, had his case heard Tuesday after failing to agree on a contract number.
Lauer (Drafted 1st round, 2016 by San Diego) is asking for $5.75 million, while the Blue Jays countered with a $4.4 million offer.
This gap of $1.35 million might seem small in the grand scheme of MLB payrolls, but the context here is fascinating.
Lauer spent 2024 pitching in Korea (KBO) before returning to the majors last season and proving he still belongs.
He posted a solid 3.18 ERA over 104.2 innings in 2025, filling a critical swingman role that saved the pitching staff during injury stretches.
His team argues that his "platform year" was strong enough to justify a raise above his previous MLB salary peak.
The Blue Jays, however, are likely pointing to his time away from the league as a reason to temper that financial jump.
Check out the latest buzz on why this ruling might take a few days to finalize: https://x.com/MitchBannon/status/2019495254190100906?s=20
A pivotal decision for the "comeback" market
This ruling isn't just about Lauer; it sets a tone for every player who goes overseas to rebuild their value.
If Lauer wins, it validates the KBO route as a legitimate path to meaningful MLB raises, not just "prove-it" deals.
For Blue Jays fans, the money doesn't matter as much as the player's role in 2026.
Lauer proved in the playoffs—where he pitched to a 3.12 ERA—that he isn't scared of the bright lights.
Having a lefty who can give you three scoreless innings or a spot start is a luxury contenders kill for.
Regardless of the arbitration result, Lauer is locked in as a key piece of the bridge to the back of the bullpen.
The front office fights for every dollar, but they know exactly how valuable "Gomer" is when the rotation falters.
Expect a decision next week, but expect Lauer to be ready to grind no matter what the paycheck says.
Also read on Toronto Baseball Insider :
Blue Jays pitcher Jose Berrios makes unexpected career announcement
Blue Jays pitcher Jose Berrios makes unexpected career announcement
| POLL | ||
FEVRIER 5|406 ANSWERS Toronto Blue Jays announce unforeseen update in Eric Lauer arbitration hearing Does Eric Lauer deserve the $5.75 million salary he is asking for? | ||
| Yes | 337 | 83 % |
| No | 69 | 17 % |
| List of polls | ||