Toronto Baseball Insider has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Blue Jays or MLB

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. draws backlash from Blue Jays fans after latest development


Victor William
Apr 20, 2026  (10:45)
Toronto Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. tosses his bat after striking out in the first inning against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chase Field.
Photo credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is still producing, but Toronto now has to manage something louder around the Blue Jays star: real fan frustration.

That reaction is easy to understand even if it is starting to overshoot the facts. Forbes noted that Guerrero has become a focus of fan anger as Toronto keeps stumbling, and that is what happens when the franchise face is attached to a club that opened 8-13.
The pressure is even hotter because Guerrero is no longer just the best hitter on the roster. He is the player the Blue Jays tied to a 14-year, $500,000,000 extension last April, a deal meant to define the franchise for the next decade and beyond.
So when the team sputters, the heat lands on him first. That is the price of being the star, the contract, and the face on the billboard all at once.
The twist is that Guerrero's line does not look like a player falling apart. Through 21 games, he is batting .319 with a .427 OBP and an .847 OPS, which is strong production by any normal standard.
But fans are not reacting to normal standards right now. They are reacting to the missing thunder, because Guerrero has only 1 home run and 8 RBI so far, and middle-of-the-order stars do not get judged softly when the club is already buried in April.
There is also the visual side of it. Guerrero's frustration has started to show in games, including a heated exchange with Milwaukee reliever Trevor Megill during a rough stretch on the road.

The Blue Jays need more than a good average from Guerrero

That is where the backlash gets real. A .319 average plays, but fans in Toronto want the version of Guerrero who changes the scoreboard with one swing and drags the lineup with him.
And to be fair, the Blue Jays need that guy, too. Daulton Varsho has been in and out, Alejandro Kirk and George Springer have dealt with injuries, and the lineup has not had enough force around Guerrero to hide quiet nights. That is an inference based on Toronto's recent injury news and record.
Still, turning on Guerrero this hard this early feels misplaced. The on-base skill is there. The contact is there. The floor is still high. What is missing is the power burst that makes everything around him look lighter.
That is the tension in Toronto now. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. is playing well enough to avoid panic, but not loudly enough to quiet a frustrated fan base that expected a franchise carrier and is still waiting for the big swings to start arriving.
POLL
4 HOURS AGO|63 ANSWERS
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. draws backlash from Blue Jays fans after latest development

Are Blue Jays fans overreacting to Vladimir Guerrero Jr.'s start ?


BLUE JAYS INSIDER
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT