The Blue Jays left Brandon Barriera exposed to the Rule 5 Draft, a telling decision on their 2022 first-round pick. Toronto didn't add the lefty to its 40-man roster Tuesday.
It was the first offseason he needed protection. The club chose to leave him off.
The 22-year-old's 2026 numbers explain why. He posted a 4.22 ERA over 12 games at Single-A Dunedin, then a 12.46 ERA in two outings at High-A Vancouver.
The Arizona Fall League didn't change the picture. He posted a 4.91 ERA over six outings.
Toronto drafted him 23rd overall out of high school. Injuries, including Tommy John surgery, have slowed him since.
Is there real risk of losing him? Probably not.
Brandon Barriera joins a 2022 first round left unprotected across MLB
Any team that selects him in the Rule 5 Draft would have to keep him in the majors all season. That's a tall ask for a pitcher with just two High-A appearances.
He's far from alone. Baseball America's J.J. Cooper noted several 2022 first-rounders were left exposed, including Termarr Johnson, Elijah Green, Dylan Lesko, Cam Collier and Mikey Romero.
Cooper framed the deadline as confirmation that the 2022 first round has been a disappointment across the league.
Toronto's 40-man is now full after it protected Nolan Perry, Daniel Guerra and RJ Schreck. There simply wasn't room for a long-term project.
It's the right call, but it stings. A first-round pick who can't crack the 40-man after four years is a draft miss, no matter how anyone spins it.
It's like a house plant you've watered for years that still hasn't flowered. You keep it, but you stop putting it in the sunny window.
There's still time. He's only 22, and pitchers coming back from major surgery sometimes need extra time to find themselves.
Barriera stays in the system for now. But the next year will decide whether he's a late bloomer or a cautionary tale for Toronto's scouting department.


















