Toronto Baseball Insider has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Blue Jays or MLB

Blue Jays clear roster space with surprising infielder DFA


Victor William
Apr 24, 2026  (9:08 PM)
Detailed view of the batting helmet of Toronto Blue Jays first baseman Vladimir Guerrero Jr. in the first inning against the Arizona Diamondbacks at Chase Field
Photo credit: Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

Tyler Fitzgerald paid the price Friday when John Schneider's Blue Jays cleared him off the 40-man roster with a designation for assignment.

Toronto announced the move alongside its trade for catcher Willie MacIver, but Fitzgerald is the real roster story here. MacIver was only the reason a spot had to open.
That matters because a DFA is not a bench shuffle or a quiet option to Triple-A. It is the kind of move that tells you a player's place in the organization has become fragile in a hurry.
Fitzgerald never really got a lane to settle in with Toronto. He arrived as infield depth, but the Blue Jays have spent the past few weeks stacking utility options and trying to protect roster flexibility wherever they can.
That made him vulnerable. Once Toronto decided it wanted MacIver's catching depth on the 40-man, Fitzgerald became the cleanest casualty.
The bigger point is positional value. Teams can patch around extra infielders more easily than they can around a thin catching chain, especially over a long season when 1 injury can ripple through multiple levels of the system.
So this was not only about Fitzgerald's own play. It was also about the kind of roster math that pushes fringe infielders out fast once a club decides another position matters more.

Toronto chose roster function over infield depth

That is what this decision says most clearly. The Blue Jays looked at their 40-man roster and decided a catcher with options was more useful than carrying Fitzgerald any longer.
It is a harsh spot for Fitzgerald because DFA moves always come with uncertainty. Toronto can still trade him, try to pass him through waivers, or outright him if he clears. But once a player reaches this point, control over the next step starts slipping away.
For Schneider's club, the move also reflects where the pressure is right now. The Blue Jays are trying to keep the roster covered at every level, not just preserve names because they might be useful later.
That is why Fitzgerald became expendable. He was not the headline addition, but he was the player without enough leverage to survive the crunch.
And those crunches are coming more often now. Toronto is juggling injuries, bullpen changes, and depth moves across the roster, which means the back end of the 40-man is going to stay under pressure.
Fitzgerald just became the latest example. Willie MacIver may have arrived quietly, but Tyler Fitzgerald is the player who felt the real impact.
For the Blue Jays, that is the takeaway. This was less a statement about MacIver and more a sign that Fitzgerald no longer held a strong enough spot to keep Toronto from moving on.
POLL
2 HOURS AGO|11 ANSWERS
Blue Jays clear roster space with surprising infielder DFA

Did the Blue Jays make the right call by designating Tyler Fitzgerald for assignment ?


BLUE JAYS INSIDER
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT