Tyler Heineman is feeling the squeeze, and John Schneider may soon have a catching decision he can't delay.
With Alejandro Kirk moving through rehab work and already back to throwing, Toronto's catching picture is starting to tighten again. Kirk fractured his left thumb in early April, underwent surgery, and was given an initial timeline of at least 6 weeks.
That matters for Heineman because he has not given the Blue Jays much room to wait. Through 54 at-bats, he is hitting .167 with a .378 OPS, and his last 15 games have been even lighter at .100.
The pressure is sharper now because Brandon Valenzuela is not just hanging around. He has pushed into the conversation with a .246 average, a .780 OPS, and 4 home runs in his first 57 at-bats.
And the trend line is even rougher for Heineman. Over his last 7 games, he is batting .105, while Valenzuela has gone .353 over the same span with 2 home runs and 7 RBI.
That is why this no longer feels like a temporary injury patch. It feels like a roster decision coming into focus, especially with both catchers currently on the active roster while Kirk works his way back.
Schneider has already shown that his patience with Heineman is not endless. Heineman was pulled on May 3 by manager's decision, then admitted afterward that his own at-bat was «pretty trash» and that he had been «pretty crappy» over roughly 10 games.
Valenzuela is making the choice harder to ignore
This is where Valenzuela changes the conversation. He is not just younger or fresher. He is producing more damage at the plate right now, and Friday's first career 4-hit game only added to that push.
He has also earned praise for what he is doing behind the plate. MLB.com noted his arm strength and game management, which is a big reason this is starting to look like more than a short hot streak.
For Toronto, the cleanest setup when Kirk returns is obvious. Kirk takes back the starting job, Valenzuela stays as the more interesting backup, and Heineman becomes the catcher with the weakest claim to an active spot.
That does not erase what Heineman gave them in 2025, when he hit .289 with a .777 OPS. But roster calls are made on what a player is giving you now, not on what he gave you last summer.
The Blue Jays do not need to force this move today because Kirk is still finishing his climb back. But the moment Kirk is cleared, Heineman looks like the catcher under the most pressure.
And unless his bat wakes up fast, Tyler Heineman has a real shot to be the next player squeezed off Toronto's roster.
Should the Blue Jays keep Brandon Valenzuela over Tyler Heineman when Alejandro Kirk returns?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Blue Jays announce MRI update on Addison Barger
