Brendon Little has pitched his way back into John Schneider's thinking, and the Blue Jays may not be able to ignore that much longer.
Little opened 2026 looking like one of Toronto's easiest roster cuts. The left-hander got tagged for 10 earned runs on 10 hits in just 3.2 innings over 5 early appearances, and the Blue Jays sent him down before the first week of April was finished.
That kind of start put him in the crosshairs fast. Fans were done with him, and after the way his 2025 season faded late, there was not much patience left for another rough stretch.
But the story has changed in Buffalo. Since the demotion, Little has gone 5-0 with a 2.49 ERA, allowing 6 earned runs and piling up 29 strikeouts in 21.2 innings across 22 Triple-A outings.
That is not just a decent reset. That is the kind of line that forces an organization to stop treating a pitcher like a failed experiment and start viewing him as usable depth again. This is an inference based on his Triple-A results and the article's framing.
The recent run is even louder. Over his last 5 appearances with Buffalo, Little has held opponents scoreless, allowed only 2 hits, and struck out 7.
That matters for this Blue Jays bullpen because left-handed options are thin. Jays Journal noted that with Joe Mantiply on the 60-day IL and Adam Macko back in the minors, Mason Fluharty is the only lefty currently in Toronto's bullpen.
Toronto suddenly has a real reason to revisit Little
That is the angle that matters most here. This is not about giving Little another chance because of sentiment. It is about roster need finally meeting better performance. This is an inference based on the bullpen context and his Buffalo numbers.
Keegan Matheson's read, as cited by Jays Journal, pushed that point clearly. He said there is going to come a time when the Blue Jays have to see if Little's stuff will translate back in the majors, especially because the club has liked what it has seen lately.
That puts pressure on Schneider and the front office. They already know what the early-season version looked like. Now they have to decide whether the Buffalo version is real enough to trust in a big-league game. This is an inference based on the contrast between his MLB and Triple-A results.
For Little, the path is pretty simple. He does not need to be a bullpen star. He just needs to give Toronto a second left-handed lane and show the command and shape that were missing in those ugly first 3.2 innings. This is an inference based on the current bullpen construction and his role.
And for the Blue Jays, there is a point where keeping him in Triple-A stops making sense. A bullpen looking for matchup help cannot keep overlooking a left-hander with a 2.49 ERA and a hot month behind him. This is an inference based on his recent results and Toronto's left-handed relief depth.
Brendon Little looked gone in April. By mid-June, he has made himself a real Blue Jays conversation again.
Should the Blue Jays bring Brendon Little back to the bullpen soon?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Blue Jays complete unexpected one for one trade with the Royals
