Spencer Miles has been a steal for John Schneider, and the Giants keep looking worse every time he takes the ball for Toronto.
That is not hype anymore. Miles was a Rule 5 pick out of the Giants' system in December 2025, and the Blue Jays have turned that gamble into one of their best roster wins of the season.
The right-hander has given Toronto 54.0 innings over 24 games, including 2 starts, with a 2.83 ERA, 55 strikeouts, a 4-1 record, and a 1.04 WHIP. For a club that has spent too much of the year searching for stable pitching, that is real value.
And it is not smoke and mirrors. Baseball Savant shows Miles has held opponents to an 85.7 mph average exit velocity while generating ground balls on 54.4% of balls in play.
That profile plays. He is not just surviving with soft matchups or weird usage. He is keeping the ball on the ground, limiting loud contact, and giving Schneider a reliever who can clean up innings without panic.
The recent run has been even better. Over his last 7 games, Miles owns a 0.68 ERA in 13.1 innings with 16 strikeouts and a 0.83 WHIP.
His latest outing drove the point home. Against the Mets on July 1, Miles worked 3.0 innings, allowed 1 hit, walked 1, and struck out 5 after opener Braydon Fisher.
Why Toronto's Rule 5 bet looks so smart
The Giants had reasons to expose him. Miles threw only 14.2 innings in their system after being drafted in the 4th round in 2022, and he went through Tommy John surgery plus another major procedure.
But Toronto saw the upside anyway. In the Arizona Fall League, Miles struck out 12 in 8.2 innings, and his fastball touched 98.2 mph, giving the Blue Jays a clear reason to take the shot.
Now the return looks enormous. Rule 5 picks are usually about roster creativity and hope. This one has become a real bullpen weapon and a pitcher Schneider can trust in meaningful spots.
That is what should sting in San Francisco. The Giants did not lose a fringe arm who never found his footing. They lost a 25-year-old righty who already looks comfortable in the majors and keeps getting stronger.
For the Blue Jays, Miles is more than a fun development story now. He has become one of the sharpest examples of this front office finding value where another club stopped looking.
And every time Spencer Miles takes the mound and shuts down another lineup, the Blue Jays look smarter for grabbing him, while the Giants look like they let the wrong arm get away.
Did the Blue Jays pull off one of the best Rule 5 steals in baseball with Spencer Miles?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Blue Jays announce major life changing news for George Springer
