Eric Lauer just gave John Schneider another reason to second-guess this trade, and Toronto's pitching mess only makes it louder.
In his first game for Los Angeles, Lauer worked 6 innings and gave up 1 run. That is exactly the kind of clean start the Blue Jays have been chasing too often lately.
With the Dodgers, Lauer is now 1-0 with a 1.50 ERA, and Arizona's official probable page lists him for Tuesday against the Diamondbacks. His next turn is already on the board.
Toronto sent Lauer to Los Angeles on May 17 for cash considerations after he opened 2026 with a 6.69 ERA for the Blue Jays. At the time, it looked like a move the club could justify.
There was real damage in that early line. Before the trade, Lauer had already allowed 11 home runs in 36.1 innings, which made him a hard arm to keep trusting every fifth day.
The problem is what happened next for Toronto. Dylan Cease went to the 15-day IL, and José Berrios was moved to the 60-day IL after Tommy John surgery.
The Blue Jays are still waiting on reinforcements, too. Max Scherzer is on a rehab assignment, and Shane Bieber is still building through rehab starts instead of helping the major-league rotation.
Why this one feels worse now
A trade that looked like roster cleanup in mid-May now looks more like lost depth. That is what changes when the rotation keeps springing leaks after the move is made.
Los Angeles made the deal because its own staff was thin, and Lauer answered at once. The Dodgers did not need him to be an ace. They needed him to be stable.
Toronto could have used exactly that while piecing together starts with call-ups, bulk plans, and rehab timelines. The Blue Jays do not need perfect right now. They need innings that hold the game together.
This does not mean the Blue Jays were reckless. Lauer's Toronto line was rough enough that moving on made baseball sense in that moment.
But when the pitcher you let go gives his new club 6 strong innings and lines up for another start the same week, the question gets louder. Was Toronto too quick to give up on a left-hander who still could help?
Eric Lauer may not solve every Blue Jays problem by himself. Still, with Toronto still short on healthy starters, this already looks like the kind of move that might age worse than the club expected.
Did the Blue Jays make a mistake by letting Eric Lauer go?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
The Twins just released a pitcher the Blue Jays know well, and a reunion in Toronto makes a lot of sense
