Toronto Baseball Insider has no direct affiliation to the Toronto Blue Jays or MLB

Eric Lauer sends message to Jose Berrios regarding losing rotation spot


Victor William
May 1, 2026  (10:23)
Toronto Blue Jays starting pitcher Eric Lauer (56) walks towards the dugout against the Minnesota Twins during the third inning at Rogers Centre.
Photo credit: Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images

Eric Lauer and John Schneider know what is coming if José Berrios is ready: Toronto's rotation gets tighter, and Lauer is the arm caught in it.

That is why Lauer's recent comments land. He has not hidden how strongly he views himself as a starter, and this latest Blue Jays shuffle drags him right back into that same fight.
Back in spring, Lauer said starting is what fits him best mentally and physically. He also said bouncing between jobs last year hurt his standing, a pointed line from a pitcher who knew exactly what that flexibility had cost him.
That context matters now because Berrios is moving toward a return. Sportsnet reported this week that Berrios believed he could be set for an MLB comeback if his rehab outing went well.
The rehab line itself was not clean. Berrios gave up 5 earned runs over 4 innings for Triple-A Buffalo, and his average fastball sat at 91.9 mph.
Still, the Blue Jays are clearly looking at the bigger picture. Berrios opened the season on the injured list with a stress fracture in his right elbow, and the club has been waiting for this decision point ever since.
Lauer has done what he can to stay in the conversation. MLB.com noted that he lost his rotation spot when Trey Yesavage returned, only to slide back in days later once Max Scherzer hit the injured list.

Eric Lauer's frustration makes sense in this spot

This is not just a numbers issue. It is a role issue, and Lauer has been blunt about that before. After following an opener earlier this month, he said, “I hate it. I can't stand it.”
That line told you a lot. Lauer is not fighting for innings in some vague way. He is fighting for the routine, the preparation, and the label that still shapes a pitcher's value around the league.
The irony is that Toronto has needed him. When Berrios went down in March, Schneider said Lauer was “firmly in the mix” for the rotation, and last season he gave the Blue Jays 104.2 innings with a 3.18 ERA.
Now the club is drifting back toward full strength, and that usually means someone useful gets squeezed. Lauer has turned into that pitcher, valuable enough to trust, but vulnerable enough to move.
That is what makes his comments hit harder than a routine depth note. He is speaking from the spot every swingman knows too well, where doing the job is not always enough to keep it.
If Berrios takes the ball next, the Blue Jays get a healthier rotation. Lauer, once again, gets the reminder that on this staff, being adaptable can still come with a price.
POLL
3 HOURS AGO|61 ANSWERS
Eric Lauer sends message to Jose Berrios regarding losing rotation spot

Should Eric Lauer stay in Toronto's rotation even if José Berríos is ready ?


BLUE JAYS INSIDER
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT