Yosver Zulueta is on the move again, and John Schneider's Blue Jays are left revisiting one of their more intriguing pitching what-ifs.
The Cubs acquired Zulueta from the Mariners on Monday for cash considerations and optioned him to Triple-A Iowa. Chicago also designated Doug Nikhazy for assignment to make the move work.
That makes this Zulueta's fourth organization in a little more than 3 months. Seattle had acquired him from Cincinnati in January, and now the Cubs are taking their own shot on a right arm that still has real life in it.
For Blue Jays fans, the move hits a little differently. Zulueta was once one of Toronto's most electric pitching prospects, the kind of arm that could light up radar guns and still leave you wondering if the command would ever catch up.
Toronto signed him as an international free agent on June 11, 2019, and the early buzz came fast. MLB.com notes he was ranked as the Blue Jays' No. 3 prospect by Baseball America after the 2022 season and No. 5 by MLB Pipeline.
That ranking made sense at the time. Zulueta had premium stuff, and Toronto pushed him hard through 4 minor-league levels in 2022 after he returned from major injury setbacks.
But that is also where the Blue Jays version of the story started to wobble. The arm was real, the upside was obvious, and the strike-throwing never became steady enough for Toronto to fully trust. This is an inference based on his prospect grades and later roster outcome.
Toronto saw the upside, but never got the payoff
Zulueta spent 2023 in Triple-A Buffalo, where he logged a 4.08 ERA with 73 strikeouts over 64 innings, but the Blue Jays never gave him the big-league look. Instead, Toronto designated him for assignment on March 28, 2024, and the Reds claimed him the same day.
That is the part Blue Jays fans will always circle. He never debuted in Toronto. His first MLB game came with Cincinnati on June 25, 2024, and not with the club that developed him.
His career has stayed uneven since. MLB's player page shows a 5.75 ERA in 22 outings this year, and that uneven track is exactly why teams keep treating him like a project instead of a finished reliever.
Still, the talent has never gone away. Seattle's January write-up noted he averaged 96.3 mph on his fastball in 2025, and that kind of arm speed is why clubs keep taking another look.
For Toronto, Zulueta remains a reminder of how thin the line can be between a breakout arm and a prospect who never quite lands. The Blue Jays found the stuff, built the hype, and watched the payoff happen somewhere else. This is an inference based on his prospect rise, DFA, and later MLB debut with Cincinnati.
Do you still wonder what Yosver Zulueta could have become with the Blue Jays?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Sportsnet just made a broadcast announcement that has fans heartbroken
