Cam Schlittler gave the Blue Jays a backhanded review, and Jamie Campbell was right to point out that it was no compliment.
After the Yankees' 2-1 loss to Toronto, Schlittler said the Blue Jays are «a team that's gonna BABIP the shit out of you,» a line that spread fast because it sounded blunt, frustrated, and more than a little dismissive.
Campbell's reaction cut to the middle of it. Calling a club a BABIP team is not praise for overwhelming talent or loud power. It is usually a way of saying they nickel-and-dime you with contact, balls in play, and pressure.
That is why the comment landed the way it did. Schlittler may have been trying to explain how Toronto's offense can wear on a pitcher, but the phrasing made it sound like the Blue Jays win with annoying little leaks instead of real quality.
Campbell did not miss that layer. He heard the line for what it was: not respect, not fear, and not admiration, but a complaint wrapped in baseball slang.
The funny part is that Schlittler's frustration still tells on Toronto in a useful way. Pitchers do not talk like that about lineups that are easy to breathe against.
-
Why Jamie Campbell's pushback hit the mark
The Blue Jays have built plenty of ugly wins on contact, traffic, and forcing pitchers to keep making throws. That style may not flatter the offense, but it still works when clubs crack first.
So when Campbell pointed out that BABIP is not a compliment, he was not overreacting. He was translating what players and broadcasters already know: there is a difference between calling a team relentless and calling them lucky.
Schlittler's quote also carried a tone problem. He was coming off a loss, which made the line sound less like scouting and more like irritation after Toronto did just enough to beat him.
That is where Campbell's read gets stronger. He was not saying Schlittler was wrong about the Blue Jays putting balls in play. He was saying the wording stripped the offense of credit.
And that is the whole point. Toronto may not bludgeon teams every night, but there is nothing accidental about making a pitcher feel like every soft landing spot just disappeared.
Campbell understood that right away. Cam Schlittler gave the Blue Jays a grudging line after a loss, and Jamie Campbell made sure nobody confused it for praise.
Was Jamie Campbell right to say Cam Schlittler's BABIP line was not a compliment?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Eric Lauer breaks silence on how Dodgers trade came together
