Eric Lauer lost his Blue Jays roster spot Monday, and John Schneider made clear the call came down to results.
Schneider called it a tough conversation because of what Lauer did for Toronto last year. But the manager said the club felt it needed to go in a different direction.
That line lands because Lauer was not some throwaway depth arm in 2025. He was one of the pitchers who helped steady the staff when the season could have started to slide.
Last year, Lauer went 9-2 with a 3.18 ERA over 104.2 innings in 28 games, including 15 starts. He also gave Toronto 8.2 postseason innings with a 3.12 ERA during its run to Game 7 of the World Series.
That is why Schneider framed this as difficult. The Blue Jays were not cutting loose a pitcher with no track record in their clubhouse. They were moving on from someone who had earned real trust not long ago.
The problem is that this season never got going. Lauer gave up 6 runs in 5.0 innings Sunday against the Angels, and Toronto designated him for assignment the next day.
That timing said plenty. The Blue Jays opened a series against the Rays needing cleaner innings, and Schneider clearly decided patience had run out.
-
Last year's value could not protect Lauer this time
This also closes the loop on a tense stretch between Lauer and the club. Earlier this season, he made it plain that he did not like working behind an opener, saying the role messed with his routine.
That frustration did not create the DFA by itself, but it added edge to a situation already being shaped by shaky outings and a staff searching for answers.
Toronto's move also tells you where the front office is leaning now. Yariel Rodriguez was selected to the roster in the same batch of moves, giving Schneider another arm as the club tries to reset its pitching mix.
For Lauer, the hard part is that last season raised the bar. Once you become a stabilizer on a contender, a rough follow-up gets judged against that standard.
And that is why Schneider's quote felt blunt but fair. He did not dismiss what Eric Lauer gave the Blue Jays in 2025. He just made clear that past value was no longer enough to hold a spot in May 2026.
The Blue Jays will move forward with a different pitching plan. Lauer now heads into roster limbo as a pitcher Toronto once leaned on, then finally decided it could not wait on any longer.
Did the Blue Jays make the right call by DFAing Eric Lauer?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Blue Jays make roster move after bad Addison Barger MRI results
