Marcus Stroman emerges as the Blue Jays’ top free-agent target
|
Victor William
Apr 10, 2026 (2:25 PM)
|
|
Photo credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images
Marcus Stroman might be headed back to Toronto after the latest update suggest he might be able to help with all of their injury problems.
That is the clean takeaway from the latest outside push around Toronto's roster. The Blue Jays do not just need better results. They need more healthy arms.
A Bleacher Report list that tied Toronto to 4 remaining free-agent pitchers: Stroman, Michael Kopech, Justin Wilson, and Tyler Anderson.
From a Blue Jays angle, that group tells you exactly where the concern sits. This club is trying to protect a season that already has rotation and bullpen stress written all over it.
Cody Ponce is expected to miss 6 months, while the article also flagged injuries around Shane Bieber, Trey Yesavage, José Berrios, Yimi Garcia, and Max Scherzer. That is a lot of traffic for April.
Kopech is the upside bullpen swing in the group. Jays Journal highlighted his 2.45 ERA and 12 strikeouts in 14 games with the Dodgers last season after a larger 2024 workload split between Los Angeles and Chicago.
Wilson is the steadier veteran relief look. The piece noted the 38-year-old went 4-1 with a 3.35 ERA and 57 strikeouts in 61 appearances for Boston in 2025.
Stroman is the name Toronto would feel most strongly
This is where the story gets more interesting for a Blue Jays audience. Anderson might fit as a bounce-back starter, but Stroman is the name that would light up the fan base fastest.
Jays Journal framed Stroman as the reunion play, even if the breakup in 2019 was messy. He spent the first 6 years of his MLB career in Toronto before being traded to the Mets, and the exit came with public frustration over how the front office handled players.
That history is why this would not be a simple baseball move. It would be a front office deciding whether a strained ending matters less now than present-day need.
The baseball case is not spotless. Stroman posted a 6.23 ERA in 9 games with the Yankees last season, so nobody should sell him as a lock to fix the rotation.
But Toronto is past the point of chasing perfect. The Blue Jays need innings, competition, and arms with some track record, even if the fit comes with risk.
That is why this 4-name list lands. Kopech, Wilson, Anderson, and Stroman all make sense in different ways. Still, Stroman is the one who feels most like a real Blue Jays story, because the need is obvious and the history would make every inning louder.
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Blue Jays dealt setback as John Schneider loses Jonatan Clase to 7-day IL
Blue Jays dealt setback as John Schneider loses Jonatan Clase to 7-day IL