Myles Straw's door back to the Blue Jays is still open, even after Toronto declined his option. The versatile outfielder could return on a cheaper deal.

Straw arrived as part of a deal for international bonus money, which the Jays hoped to use on Roki Sasaki. Sasaki chose the Dodgers instead.

His 2025 turned out well by his standards. He posted 2.8 WAR over 137 games.

The 2026 season was rougher. His OPS fell to .646, and his wRC+ dipped to 83.

He was streaky from month to month. But he finished strong, hitting .300 over his final 22 games.

So why bring him back? The glove.

Myles Straw's Gold Glove defence still fits Toronto's bench

The 2022 Gold Glove winner can handle all three outfield spots. He made several highlight-reel catches in 2026.

He also served as a veteran presence for young outfielders like Brett Bateman.

Toronto values that kind of versatility. The Jays won the AL Team Gold Glove this season, and defence remains a core part of their identity.

The free-agent pool is thin, too. A backup center fielder who can also cover the corners is harder to find than it sounds.

Re-signing him at the right price is a no-brainer. Declining the option was smart, but letting a glue guy who wants to be here walk away would be a mistake.

Straw is like a reliable umbrella stand by the front door. You barely notice it until a storm hits and everyone reaches for it.

There's competition, though. YanksGoYard's Stephen Parello urged the Yankees to target him once he hit the market.

The ball is in Ross Atkins' court. If the Jays move quickly, Straw could be back in the outfield mix before the lockout hits on Dec. 1.