Sid Seixeiro isn't a fan of what the Toronto Blue Jays just gave up, and he's making that clear on his radio show.
Toronto sent Arjun Nimmala, one of its top prospects, to the Angels in exchange for starting pitcher Jose Soriano.
Seixeiro doesn't like the deal, and he hasn't been shy about voicing that opinion publicly.
Soriano brings real substance to the trade, sitting at 9-6 with a 3.37 ERA across 22 starts this season, striking out 127 batters over 123 innings, genuine frontline production for a controllable arm.
That kind of performance makes the return understandable on paper, but parting with a prospect like Nimmala clearly rubs some observers the wrong way given his standing within the organization.
Toronto sits at 50-59, last in the American League East, a season that's forced this front office into moving several veterans, but adding Soriano represented one of the rare additions rather than subtractions at this deadline.
Fans, however, have pushed back hard against Seixeiro's take, with plenty arguing he simply doesn't understand the full picture of what this trade actually represents for Toronto's rotation going forward.
Why this disagreement reflects a bigger split in evaluation
Radio hosts and media personalities often take strong public stances on trades, and pushback from engaged fan bases has become a predictable part of that dynamic in the social media era.
The core of this disagreement seems to come down to how each side values Nimmala's long-term ceiling against Soriano's immediate, multi-year rotation impact.
It's a bit like two people watching the same movie and walking away with completely different opinions about whether the ending actually worked.
Does giving up a top prospect like Nimmala for a controllable starter like Soriano represent smart asset management, or does it risk looking like a mistake years down the road if Nimmala develops into a star?
Whatever side fans land on, this trade has clearly become one of the more debated moves of Toronto's entire deadline.
Do you agree with Sid Seixeiro that the Blue Jays gave up too much for Jose Soriano?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Blue Jays sign former Marlins right hander after trade deadline
