George Springer and Jeff Hoffman are staring at a Blue Jays deadline question that would have sounded strange a year ago.
A recent report argued Toronto has 2 veteran players it can move before the trade deadline: Springer and Jeff Hoffman. For a club sitting at 34-38 and 2 games back of the final AL wild-card spot, that idea is no longer hard to imagine.
The Springer part is the bigger shock. He hit 32 home runs, drove in 84, and batted .309 over 140 games in 2025, but this season he has fallen to 6 home runs and a .208 average through 50 games.
That is not just a cold patch. That is the kind of drop that forces a front office to stop looking at the back of the baseball card and start looking at the active roster instead. This last sentence is an inference based on Springer's 2025 and 2026 lines.
The contract is part of it too. Springer is in the final season of his deal, which makes him easier to discuss in trade scenarios if Toronto stays outside the playoff line deep into July.
The roster squeeze only sharpens that angle. Jays Journal noted Addison Barger is expected back soon, and that return could take more at-bats away from a veteran already getting outplayed by other outfield options on the roster.
Jeff Hoffman may be the cleaner deadline move
Hoffman is a different case, but the logic still tracks. The right-hander has a 5.64 ERA in 33 appearances, and Jays Journal pointed out he already lost the closer role earlier this season because of his struggles.
That makes him easier to shop than Springer in one important way. A contender could still talk itself into Hoffman as a change-of-scenery bullpen arm rather than a declining everyday player. This is an inference based on his role and Jays Journal's framing.
There is at least a little recent life in the profile. Hoffman allowed just 1 earned run in 5 appearances to open June, which gives Toronto something better to sell than his full-season line.
The Blue Jays do not have to become full sellers to make either move. That is one of the smarter points in the piece. Trading Springer or Hoffman could be more about reshaping the roster than punting on the season.
And that is really the heart of it. Toronto is not being asked to tear down its core. It is being asked to decide whether 2 veterans still fit a club that needs cleaner production and sharper roster efficiency. This is an inference based on the article's argument that both could be replaced by upgrades.
Springer would be the emotional move. Hoffman would be the more practical one. But if the Blue Jays want to add without standing still, both names make sense as players who could be moved before the deadline.
Should the Blue Jays move George Springer or Jeff Hoffman before the deadline?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
The Blue Jays announce that they have traded Tyler Heineman
