Alejandro Kirk left John Schneider with a real problem Saturday after X-rays revealed a fractured thumb and forced the catcher onto the injured list.
That turned Friday's ugly scene in Chicago into something much worse for Toronto. What looked like a painful exit after a foul tip is now a roster hit the Blue Jays can feel right away.
Kirk took the foul tip off his left thumb in the 10th inning of Toronto's 5-4 loss to the White Sox on Friday and walked off with the training staff almost immediately. MLB.com reported after the game that he underwent X-rays on the thumb.
The Blue Jays could not really afford bad news here. Kirk is one of the lineup's most important contact bats, and Keegan Matheson wrote Friday that outside of Vladimir Guerrero Jr., he is one of the hitters Toronto can least afford to lose.
That is what makes the fracture news hit harder than a normal early-season IL move. This is not a bench piece going down for 10 days. This is the catcher who helps hold the whole game together behind the plate.
Toronto opened the season with only Kirk and Tyler Heineman on the active roster behind the plate, which meant any real Kirk injury was always going to expose the club's thin catcher depth. MLB.com's Opening Day roster breakdown pointed to Brandon Valenzuela in Triple-A as the obvious next option if a need came up.
That need is here now, and fast. The Blue Jays are not just replacing at-bats. They are trying to replace game-calling, receiving, and a catcher the staff leans on every night.
-
Toronto's depth chart just got tested
Heineman can step in and steady things for a stretch, but the shape of the roster changes the second Kirk is out. Heineman moves from backup to main catcher, and the margin for error behind him gets a lot tighter.
Valenzuela is the name that matters next. MLB.com and Sportsnet both had him lined up as Toronto's first catcher depth option this season after he made the 40-man roster and opened the year at Triple-A Buffalo.
There is a reason the Blue Jays liked that setup. MLB's prospect writeup on Valenzuela says the present package already looks like that of a solid MLB backup, which is exactly what Toronto suddenly needs.
Still, this is a tough way to get pushed into that decision. Toronto is already juggling pitching issues and just watched its lineup stall in a 10-inning loss Friday. Losing Kirk on top of that adds another pressure point to a club that has not looked sharp for several days.
The bigger issue is simple. Kirk is not easy to replace because the drop from him to the rest of the depth chart is real, even if Valenzuela is a useful call-up.
That is why this story matters beyond the injury report. Alejandro Kirk is on the injured list, his thumb is fractured, and the Blue Jays now have to find out how sturdy their catcher depth really is.
Will the Blue Jays really feel Alejandro Kirk's absence right away?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Mason Fluharty start leaves Blue Jays lineup under microscope
