Nathan Lukes is drawing trade interest, according to the Toronto Star's Gregor Chisholm. But with the Blue Jays' outfield depth thinning, moving him now would be risky.

Lukes has been a regular for the past two seasons. Over that span, he's hit .266 with 22 homers and a 103 wRC+.

He's also been worth 4.0 fWAR across 2025 and 2026, thanks to both his bat and his glove.

His defence earned him a Gold Glove finalist nod in right field. He posted +11 Defensive Runs Saved over 786.2 innings there.

He's projected to earn $2.1 million in the first of four arbitration years as a Super Two player.

So why would Toronto move him? Age and fit.

Nathan Lukes' value grows as Blue Jays outfield depth shrinks

Lukes turned 32 in July, and most of his production has come against right-handed pitching. Brett Bateman, another lefty bat, offers stronger defence in center.

Toronto has been linked to several outfielders, including Seiya Suzuki, Teruaki Sato, Trent Grisham and old friend Daulton Varsho. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is also open to a multi-position role.

But the depth chart has gotten thinner. The Jays declined Myles Straw's option and non-tendered Davis Schneider on Friday.

Without Lukes, the backup outfield would lean on utility and inexperienced options like Josh Smith, Jonatan Clase and RJ Schreck.

Keep him until the replacement arrives. Trading Lukes before landing Suzuki or Sato would leave Toronto exposed behind a shaky group of Bateman, Barger and Santander.

It's like selling your spare tire before buying new ones. Fine in theory, but one flat and you're stuck on the shoulder.

Once the Jays add an everyday outfielder, the calculus changes. Then Lukes becomes a valuable, cheap trade chip.

The interest is a good sign for his value. The smart play for Ross Atkins is to sequence the moves: sign first, trade second.