The Blue Jays have lost Jonathan Loaisiga to the Yankees. The reliever agreed Friday to a two-year deal worth about $18 million, with a club option for 2029.

MLB.com's Mark Feinsand reported the terms, while ESPN's Jorge Castillo confirmed the option year.

Toronto had been among several teams interested. Losing him to a division rival makes the miss sting even more.

It's a homecoming for the 32-year-old. Loaisiga spent the first eight seasons of his career in New York.

He re-established himself in Arizona in 2026, posting a 2.42 ERA over a career-high 67 appearances.

What made him so attractive? Elite control and a heavy fastball.

Jonathan Loaisiga's return strengthens the Yankees' bullpen rebuild

His fastball averaged 97.8 m.p.h., and his walk rate ranked in the 96th percentile. He leaned on a power sinker to generate ground balls.

The Yankees are rebuilding their relief corps quickly. Closer David Bednar accepted his $23.15 million qualifying offer, and lefty Tim Hill re-signed.

“I would describe it as drinking out of a fire hose right now,” Brian Cashman said of his offseason talks.

The Jays finished last in the AL East at 79-83. The Yankees were second behind Tampa Bay.

Toronto should have pushed harder at this price. Two years at roughly $9 million a season for a durable groundball reliever was exactly the kind of deal Ross Atkins said he'd target.

It's like watching your neighbour grab the last affordable house on the street. You hesitated, and now you'll be looking at it every day.

The bullpen remains a strength, led by Louis Varland and Tyler Rogers. But the hunt for another leverage arm, especially a lefty, continues.

Alex Vesia and A.J. Minter remain on Toronto's radar. Atkins can't afford to watch another target land in New York before the Dec. 1 deadline.