Ross Atkins sees Ricky Tiedemann as a reliever moving forward, and that could solve the Blue Jays' search for a second lefty. The former top prospect's starting days may be over.
“I would love for him to somehow do something to change that,” Atkins told Sportsnet's Shi Davidi. “But most likely thinking about him as a reliever, could grow into some bulkier outings.”
That's a big shift for a pitcher once viewed as a future front-line starter. The Jays took him in the third round in 2021.
Injuries changed the path. He had Tommy John surgery in July 2024 and missed all of 2025.
He finally debuted on Aug. 15 against the Yankees. Across five big-league games, he posted a 1.50 ERA with eight strikeouts over six innings.
Why does this matter now? Because Mason Fluharty can't carry the lefty load alone again.
Ricky Tiedemann could ease Mason Fluharty's workload in 2027
Fluharty led all of baseball with 83 appearances, largely because John Schneider had few other left-handed options.
Toronto has been linked to free-agent lefty A.J. Minter. But Tiedemann could give the Jays an internal answer.
Control is the concern. He walked six batters in those six innings, good for a 1.83 WHIP.
Other lefties could help, too. Brendan Cellucci posted a 3.06 ERA with 10.2 strikeouts per nine at Triple-A, and Brendon Little rebounded with a 2.04 ERA after an August recall.
This changes how Toronto should view Tiedemann in trade talks. He's been floated in several proposals as surplus depth, but a cheap, hard-throwing lefty reliever is exactly what this bullpen lacks.
It's like realizing the tool you were about to sell is the exact one your project needs. Sometimes the answer is already in the garage.
That doesn't mean the Jays should skip the market entirely. One proven lefty plus Tiedemann would give Schneider real options.
His career didn't follow the script anyone wrote in 2021. But a new role in the bullpen might finally let that talent stick in Toronto.


















