Brandon Valenzuela enters the offseason with John Schneider facing a new question: how much more can Toronto ask from its rookie catcher?
Valenzuela's first MLB season changed his standing inside the organization. He appeared in 91 games after Toronto initially called him up when starting catcher Alejandro Kirk went down.
The 26-year-old hit .226 with 9 home runs and a .688 OPS. His work behind the plate also helped him finish the season with 1.6 bWAR.
Now Valenzuela has addressed Blue Jays fans directly. In an Instagram message after the season, he thanked Toronto for giving him the opportunity to reach the majors and stressed that he still has work ahead.
That message fits a player whose rookie year moved faster than expected. Valenzuela went from catching depth to receiving regular MLB innings while Toronto dealt with Kirk's absence.
And his opportunity didn't disappear once Kirk returned. The Blue Jays instead moved Tyler Heineman to the Los Angeles Angels, clearing the backup catching job for Valenzuela.
Brandon Valenzuela forces a new Blue Jays decision
That roster move said plenty about how Toronto viewed Valenzuela. Rather than send the rookie back down, the Blue Jays created room to keep his glove and bat on the major-league roster.
His path to Toronto had already developed quickly. The Blue Jays acquired Valenzuela from the San Diego Padres for infielder Will Wagner at the 2025 trade deadline.
At the time, the deal added catching depth. One year later, Toronto has a young backstop who has already handled an extended major-league workload and established himself behind Kirk.
The next question involves playing time. Valenzuela can return as Kirk's backup, but his rookie season gives Toronto reason to consider finding extra at-bats rather than limiting him to occasional starts behind the plate.
Designated hitter could offer that opening. George Springer's expected departure in free agency would remove one veteran from the DH picture and potentially create more flexibility for Schneider's lineup card.
Valenzuela still has to prove his bat can hold up across another full season. His offensive production cooled late, making his second-year adjustments at the plate one of the more interesting developments to watch.
But the rookie already cleared the first hurdle. Toronto gave him an opportunity, then changed its roster to keep him. His next challenge is turning that foothold into a bigger role.
Should Brandon Valenzuela get more at-bats next season?
Voting closed


















