Max Scherzer gave John Schneider a real sign of progress Tuesday, finishing 2 innings of live batting practice and moving closer to a rehab game.
That matters because this was no light throwing day. Live BP is the checkpoint where recovery starts looking less like controlled work and more like a real pitching plan.
Scherzer faced hitters in Toronto and got through 2 innings of work. In one sequence, he even froze Blue Jays analyst Gosuke Katoh for a called strike, a small moment that still added some life to the update.
The bigger takeaway is what comes next. Shi Davidi reported that Scherzer's next step could be a rehab outing, which is exactly where Toronto wanted this progression to go.
That changes the tone around his recovery. A couple of weeks ago, the Blue Jays were still talking about bullpens and whether Scherzer was ready to face hitters at all.
Now he has cleared that part. Once a starter gets through live hitters cleanly, the conversation stops being about buildup and starts becoming about game volume.
Toronto needs that badly. Scherzer has been on the injured list with right forearm tendinitis and left ankle inflammation, and the Blue Jays have spent much of the season patching together innings around rotation injuries.
-
Why Max Scherzer's live BP matters now
This was always going to be the real hinge point. A veteran can feel good in a bullpen, but facing hitters tells the club much more about how the stuff plays, how the arm recovers, and whether the next day brings any trouble.
That is why the rehab-outing talk lands. It means Scherzer is no longer just testing the arm. He is getting close to the part of recovery where pitch count, innings, and results begin to matter again.
The Blue Jays do not need Scherzer back as a novelty. They signed him to stabilize starts and give the staff one more experienced arm, even if his first 5 outings of 2026 were uneven. He posted a 9.64 ERA before landing on the IL.
That rough line is exactly why this update carries some tension. Toronto needs the healthy version, not just the famous name. A rehab assignment would be the first real chance to see whether Scherzer is building toward that.
There is still work left before anyone talks about activation dates. Live BP is a strong step, but it is not the finish line, and the Blue Jays still have to see how his body responds before locking in the next move.
Still, this was one of Scherzer's clearest forward steps yet. He got through 2 innings against hitters, looked sharp enough to catch a lefty looking, and pushed the Blue Jays to the edge of the next phase.
For Toronto, that is the whole point of the update. Max Scherzer is no longer just throwing. He is closing in on a rehab outing, and that makes his return feel a lot more real than it did a week ago.
Will Max Scherzer make a real impact for the Blue Jays once he returns?
Also read on Blue Jays Insider :
Blue Jays are doing something unexpected with their rotation for the Orioles series - and it's turning heads
