MLB Trade Rumors' Steve Adams predicts Randy Arozarena will sign with the Blue Jays, not Seiya Suzuki. It's a different read than most around Toronto expected.

Adams called Arozarena “the game's most consistent 20-20 performer.” He added that the former ALCS MVP still hits the ball hard, even as his swing slows down.

Adams also noted the outfielder “still draws walks at a comfortably above-average rate despite this year's uptick in chases.”

Like Suzuki, Arozarena has a shot at four-plus years, Adams believes, a rare deal for a 32-year-old.

There's one catch. Adams pointed out Arozarena may have fewer suitors because he's limited to left field.

So who's right? Bleacher Report predicted Suzuki to Toronto on a five-year, $145 million deal.

Randy Arozarena's left field limits could cost the Blue Jays

The need is clear either way. MLB.com's Keegan Matheson wrote that “the Blue Jays need to find their next George Springer.”

Suzuki has been the name tied to Toronto longest. The Athletic's Mitch Bannon reported in September that the Jays were expected to pursue him.

Arozarena played on a $15 million deal with the Mariners in 2026. His speed would add a dimension the Jays lacked after ranking 27th in steals.

But the glove is a concern. A player locked into left field limits Toronto's flexibility, with Anthony Santander and Addison Barger also in the corner mix.

Suzuki is still the better fit. His on-base skills address Toronto's biggest weakness, while Arozarena's chase uptick and defensive limits make a four-year deal riskier than it looks.

Arozarena is the flashy sports car, Suzuki the reliable SUV. Both get you there, but only one handles winter roads without drama.

The former Mariner does bring East Coast appeal. He reportedly prefers a team that trains in Florida, which Dunedin offers.

The predictions may differ, but the message is the same. Toronto is expected to land one of the top two outfield bats, and Ross Atkins can't afford to miss on both.